---
title: "Peer Review Template — Stop, Start, Continue Feedback | Crewmojo"
description: "A peer feedback set built on stop, start, continue — specific enough to act on, safe enough that people answer honestly. Take it and change it."
source: https://www.crewmojo.com/performance-management-templates/peer-review-template
published: 2022-12-01
modified: 2026-10-12
generated: 2026-11-20
---

[All templates](https://www.crewmojo.com/performance-management-templates)

# Peer review template

A peer feedback set built on stop, start, continue — specific enough to act on, safe enough that people answer honestly. Take it and change it.

7 questions · Performance reviews

## The template

### Context

Ask this first. A reviewer who has barely worked with someone should be able to say so, and their answer should be weighted accordingly.

1.  How closely have you worked with this person over the period?

### Continue

What is working. First, because it is the easiest to write and it sets the reviewer up to be specific rather than cautious.

1.  What does this person do that you would want them to keep doing?
2.  When did they make your work easier or better? Give one example.

### Start

The growth question, framed as addition rather than fault. People write far more useful answers here than to "what are their weaknesses".

1.  What is one thing you would like to see them do more of, or start doing?
2.  What would make the biggest difference to how you work together?

### Stop

Optional, and say so on the form. A forced criticism is usually an invented one.

1.  Is there anything that gets in the way of working well with them?

### One rated question

A single statement, so there is something comparable across reviewers without turning the exercise into scoring.

-   I would choose to work with this person again 1 2 3 4 5

## What this one assumes

There is more than one way to run this. Here is what we assumed, so you can tell quickly whether it fits — and what to change if it does not.

-   Peers are chosen because they have actually worked with the person, not because they sit nearby
-   Three or four reviewers is enough — more produces averaging, not accuracy
-   Feedback goes to the person, with the manager seeing it as context rather than as a score
-   Nothing here produces a rating — peer input informs a judgement, it does not make one

## Why stop, start, continue

Peer feedback fails in two directions. Asked openly — "any feedback on this person?" — most people write something warm and useless. Asked as a rating grid, they produce numbers that say nothing about what to do differently.

Stop, start, continue works because it asks for actions rather than judgements. It is easy to write, because the reviewer is describing behaviour rather than assessing a person. And it is easy to receive, which matters more than it sounds: feedback only changes anything if the person can read it without becoming defensive.

## How the template is built

**Context first.** A reviewer who worked with someone twice should be able to say so. Without this question their answer carries the same weight as a daily collaborator's, and the person receiving it has no way to tell the difference.

**Continue before start.** The order is doing real work. Opening with what someone should keep doing gets the reviewer writing specifically, and specificity carries into the harder questions. Opening with criticism gets a cautious, hedged form.

**Start, not improve.** "What would you like to see them do more of" and "what are their weaknesses" produce completely different answers to the same underlying question. The first gets written honestly; the second gets avoided or softened into nothing.

**Stop is optional and labelled optional.** Most working relationships have nothing in this category, and a required field invents one. Leaving it blank should be a legitimate answer.

**One rated question.** "I would choose to work with this person again" is the single statement worth comparing across reviewers. It captures the thing peers actually know and nothing else on the form can tell you.

## How to run it

Let the person nominate some of their own reviewers, and add one or two they did not pick. Fully self-selected panels are generous; fully assigned ones miss the people who know the work best.

Give the person their feedback before their manager discusses it with them. Being in the room while someone else reads your peer feedback for the first time is the worst version of this process.

Three or four reviewers is the right number. Beyond that the themes repeat, the admin grows, and the averaging hides the one answer that mattered.

## What we would change, and when

If this is the first time peer feedback has run in your organisation, drop the stop question entirely for the first cycle. Establish that the process is safe before asking people to put criticism in writing about someone they sit next to.

For a team where everyone works with everyone — a small studio, a pod — reduce it to continue and start only. The context question is redundant and the rated statement gets awkward when the whole team is reviewing the whole team.

If peer input is feeding a promotion decision, say that on the form. People calibrate what they write to the stakes, and discovering the stakes afterwards is how organisations lose trust in a review process.

## Run this one, then change it

Load it into Crewmojo as a starting point and reshape the questions, the timing and who is involved around how your organisation actually works.

[Book a demo](https://www.crewmojo.com/demo)
